Omantribune
Oman Tribune
Omantribune
Omantribune Search News
Web Oman
    Google Search Button
      Tribune
- Oman
- Soccer World Cup
- Other Top Stories
- Middle East
- Business
- Sports
- India
- Pakistan
- Asia
- Europe
- Americas
- Columnists
- Editorial
- Oman Mirror
- Special Features
- Cinema
- PDF Pages
- Weather
- Travel
- Currency Rate
- Hospitals
- Pharmacies
- Services
- Flight Timings
- Museum Timings
Omantribune Home Omantribune About Us Omantribune Advertising Information Omantribune Archives Omantribune Subscribe-Form Omantribune Jobs Omantribune Contact Us
Tuesday, September 02, 2014  
Justice for all

by Javed Hafiz
Politics bereft of ethics can indeed become tyranny

For Aristotle politics and ethics were inter-related. He thought the ultimate objective of human existence was happiness. But humans cannot achieve a state of happiness the way animals do. Humans are social and contemplative animals. The best way to ensure human happiness was to provide justice for all. Justice could be of two kinds; distributive and remedial. Justice is based on virtue which is inseparable from ethics. Therefore, the final objective of any political entity or state should be maximum happiness of the people which could be achieved only by a system based on ethical norms.

In the Third World, it is generally thought that all is fair in politics. A political party strives to get into the corridors of power and ends justify means. All means, fair and foul, can be employed to achieve the desired results. The hallowed  concept of democracy is used by the selected few to get into government in order to further individual or party objectives. Who said democracy is a government of the people, by the people and for the people? Those are theoretical concepts confined to the books. Is the yawning gap between politics and ethics in the Third World a permanent feature? To me it is an indication of political immaturity which can be cured with further practice of democracy and spread of education.

Pakistan, being an Islamic country,  should set high ethical standards for its political leaders. But unfortunately that is not the case. The voter expects the politician to get him the village road, help him with the local police and arrange suitable jobs for his kith and kin. Whether the political leader is a saint or satan, is not important for the voters. As opposed to this, the voters in the developed democracies are far more discerning. In the West, if you hold a public office, your life is public property and you have to adhere to certain moral standards. President Clinton had to apologise for his extra marital laison with Monica Lewinsky, but President Estrada of the Phillipines had no problem keeping quite a few mistresses.

And then within one country, people expect different moral standards from different leaders and parties. If a People’s party leader is caught telling a lie, it is no big deal. But if Imran Khan admits old politicians into his party , he is severely criticised. Remember Nawaz Sharif had said several times that he would never ever entertain pro-Musharraf politicians. Now they are joining his party in droves. Nobody has taken him to task for that move. In his case, it is considered smart politics. Obviously  the people of Pakistan judge Nawaz Sharif and Imran Khan by different ethical standards. If President Zardari reneges on a written promise, he is considered smart but if a Jamat e Islami leader had done the same, he would face strong criticism.

But that does not mean that all Pakistanis approve corruption and double standards. The reason that Chief Justice Chaudhary has become so popular is that he wants accountability across the board. A friend of mine, who teaches at a prestigious university and is considered an authority on Pakistani politics, says corruption is only a middle class problem. But I do not agree with him. Corruption, for example, hinders fair and merit oriented distribution of job opportunities. This adversely affects the poor segments  the most as they do not  have the capacity to pay bribes.

One essential function of the political leadership is to serve as a vital link between the people and the state. With so much population and poor security environment, it is no longer possible for the leaders to hold public meetings so often or to receive every body in their offices. But modern technology can be used to bring the rulers and the ruled closer. For example, the Punjab government has devised a system in which ordinary citizens can lodge complaints against corrupt practices of officials by SMS or by phone calls. The recorded voice of the Chief Minister Shahbaz Sharif welcomes every complainant. People lodging complaints are promptly attended to by the chief minister’s staff by way of return calls. This has helped in bringing the level of corruption down in Punjab.

 In my opinion, ethics and politics can be and indeed should be combined for the sake of general  good. Ethics indeed provides the state with a strong basis and justification. With the increase in wealth  and population, the need for the distributive as well as remedial justice has increased. Politics bereft of ethics can indeed become tyranny.

Oman Tribune

Other comment for Javed Hafiz

Theories galore

Highly inconsistent

Futile exercises

Fluid scenario

Terror has no limits

Sharif under pressure

Challenges for Sharif

Anti-terror weapon

Times of trouble

Diplomacy futile

Sparkling no more

Losing glamour

Wrong notions

Challenges ahead

The impulsive Khan

Tough equation

Media mess

Sanity returns

Whiff of fresh air

No dull moment

Fighting terror

Flavour of the season

Sunny days

Different strategy

Back to square one

Crucial talks

Jerky road ahead

Changing dynamics

Towards change

Uncertain scenario

In a terrible jam

Crucial visit

New possibilities

No ordinary judge

Crucial Sharif visit

Farewell to the army

A whack for the general

Imran acts tough

Challenging tasks

Deadly blow

New phase in ties

Pakistanís obsession

Man of the past

Honeymoon over?

Senseless carnage

China surges ahead

Strategic dialogue

Hero or villain?

Worried Sharif

No place for Taliban

Unorthodox and naive

Democracy takes roots

Turning paranoid

Noose tightens

Crucial visit

Mending fences

Yet another storm

Numerous problems

Economic blues

The best bet

Dismal performance

Complex mind

Whiff of fresh air

Political maturity

The wild card

In a soup

Bizarre stuff

Radical plan

Not a saviour

The big poll battle

Strategic decisions

Conspiracy theories

Poll fever rises

Potent issue

The best bet

More bickering

Judicial whiplash

Roller-coaster ride

Promoting peace

New worries

Justice for all

Tough days

Total suspense

Reversible decline

Political games

Unsavoury trends

Learning process

Eyes on US

Clear message

Asian blessing

Fast comeback

Not at the top

Pakistanís progress

Win for rule of law

Taliban peace signs?

Afghan refugees

The divorce option

Waziristan action

The real war

Happy Zardari

Right step

Strange signs

Exciting times

Futile exercise

Iceberg thaws

Modern pygmies

Change crucial

The last hope

At a crossroads

No ordinary person

Controversial trip

Boiling anger

Gains vanish

Complicated problem

More uncertainty

Himalayan folly

Significant visit

Murder and mayhem

Rudderless ship

Realistic goals

Ladies with a face

Out of the groove

The Baloch tangle

Different views

No more holy cows

Dream comes true

Media and the message

Under courtís orders

Civil-military flare-up

Aim to fight and talk

Anxious uncertainties

Wishful thinking

Blessing in disguise

In the line of fire

New storm

Fireworks ahead

Pakistani dilemma

The big bang

Music to the ears

Big breakthrough

On the streets again

Attack not an option

Allies at odds

Huge disappointment

Extremism still alive

Humbling experience

Politics of a diatribe

Perform and get paid

Method in madness

A terrible mess

Sky is the limit

Simmering cauldron

Sheer arrogance

Uncertainty ahead

Still strong

Whiff of fresh air

Karzaiís sweet words

Terror has no religion

Path to Afghan peace

Army in the dock

Allís fair in politics

World safer

Deaf, dumb, blind

Understanding reality

Challenges lie ahead

Confrontation ahead

Peace through sports

Honour vs national interest

A political gimmick

The gathering clouds

Poet of love and peace

Cabinet reshuffle

Balochistan blues

State of affairs in Pakistan

The Lahore episode

Pakistan-Iran relations

Bidenís visit to Pakistan

The economic scene

Troubled government

A landmark visit

Political roller-coaster

Afghan quagmire

The WikiLeaks and after

Politics of taxation

wake-up call to government

Civil-military relations

War on corruption

Strange bedfellows

Judges on the offensive

Natoís crucial lifeline

Musharraf re-enters politics

On presidential immunity

On the boil again

Zardariís two years in office

Afghan reality check

Fractured relief effort

Altaf Hussainís statement

The deluge and after

Possible return of Musharraf

Zardariís European excursion

Civil-military relations

War-centric bilateral ties

Ambivalent opposition

Mid-term elections?

The exit of McChrystal

ISI in spotlight

Need to tighten belt

Nuclear diplomacy

Clash of institutions

Endgame in Afghanistan

Next round of legal battles

Faisal Shahzad episode

Lahore, now and then

Clash of institutions

Of politics and morality

Iran-Pakistan oil pipeline

Constitutional purge

Judicial appointments

Strategic dialogue with US

Womenís forward march

Twin brothers

The prodigal son

A chastened United States

Pakistanís bizarre drama

Afghanistan peace hurdles

State of economy

Vindication of policy

Neighbourhood taxes

Presidential speech

The decision and after

Two historic decisions

Three cheers for the two

Afghan exit strategy

The cat out of the bag

Pakistanís nuclear arsenal

Zardariís future

Hillary Clinton in Pakistan

Zardari-Sharif meeting

South Waziristan offensive

Attack on the GHQ

Skeleton in the cupboard

Aid with strings

Afghan scenarios

New education policy

An appraisal of Zardari

Musharrafís trial?

Minus one formula

Elections in Afghanistan

After Baitullah

A landmark judgment

Interesting times

Judicial activism

Never the twain shall meet?

The madrasa challenge

From Swat to Waziristan

Good friends

Taliban phenomenon

Administrative decline

Zardariís US visit

Resilient Pakistan

Need for progress

Realities of economy

Leader with a vision

Af-Pak plan realistic

Iran-US relations

Third time lucky

Diplomacy to journalism

The numbers game

Turbulence ahead

Another deal in Swat

Difficult mission

Natural philanthropists

Balance of power

Drones vs hearts

For stability and peace

Rising pessimism

Alive and kicking

Restraint necessary

Cartographerís fantasy

Discipline crucial

Foreign policy challenge

Pointless exercise

Love and hate

Enduring relations

Fragile situation

Terror strikes at will

Remembering my Ramadan days in Mideast

Better placed

Ideological rift

Mr Unreliable

Brief encounters

Deep trouble

Right time to invest

Cooperation necessary

Changed thinking

Troubled times

Laudable EU move

Uncertainty ahead

Major dilemma

Strong message

Complex issues

Future bright for trade

Pakistanis disappointed

Marshall Plan needed

Suspense in Pakistan

Archives
- Back to columns -
NEWS UPDATES
Oman
Meeting discusses safety at sea, pollution from ships
Haitham, Italian envoy discuss cultural issues
Archaeological site visitors rise
Second chance for registration for higher education
Constructions continue in wadis despite warnings
Orpic starts plan for women
Sewage plan to see big leap by í20
Other Top Stories
Lesotho PM seeks help from African states to restore order
Syria army, rebels clash in Golan
Militias take control of Tripoli
Afghan talks on power-sharing deal collapse
Iran holds talks with IAEA on nuke research
India
Court urged to halt scrapping of some coal blocks
Government move on Teacherís Day event draws alliesí anger
Tejinder arrested in Tatra bribery case
Gujarat to host Asiaís maiden ballistic research centre
Kerala to observe shutdown over RSS manís killing
Nalanda opens after 800 years
Delhi, Tokyo pledge to develop closer, strategic partnership
Modi deplores some nationsí Ďexpansionismí
Special team in PMO will fast-track Japanese investments: PM
UDF, LDF playing vote bank politics: Shah
Two Badaun rape accused get bail
Pakistan
Protesters storm PTV building
Hashmi claim of PTI-military links denied
School reopening hit as IDPs stay put in Khyber
Journalists face protestersí anger in capital
Federal Womenís University to be launched in Islamabad
Middle East
Huthi chief issues civil disobedience call in Yemen stir
AQAP kills three for helping drone raids
Germany to send weapons to Iraqi Kurds fighting IS rebels
Salman to hold talks with Hollande in Paris
War cost Hamas half of its arsenal, but helped cement clout
Wounded Gazans find it tough to get long-term care
Asia
HK democracy activists heckle Chinese official
Knifeman kills 3 kids, jumps to death at Chinese school
Philippines foils airport bomb plot, 4 arrested
China varsity urges fight against ruling party criticism
2 die in NZ welfare office shooting, suspect held
N. Korea limits touristsí phone use
Business
Euro zone, Asia factory activity slows in Aug.
Japan to invest $34b in India over next 5 years
Russia starts construction of $20.8b gas pipeline to China
Microsoft gets 20 days to reply in anti-trust probe
Nifty surges past 8,000 points, Sensex hits record
Reliance, Nippon launch funds for Japan investors
RBI ban on banksí bond purchase hits infrastructure funding options
Micromax pips Apple in India
Maruti, Honda lead India sales
Investors wait for ECB move
Germany runs up GDP surplus of 1.1% in first half
China manufacturing growth slows in August
Europe
Kiev troops abandon airport
British terror suspects Ďmay lose passportsí
UK brain tumour boyís kin resist extradition
Muslim engineer N-site ban upheld
French Socialists upset over PMís ĎTony Blair-styleí lurch
Sports
Al Harthy boosts title challenge
US, Spain continue fairytale run at Worlds
Zurutuza brace helps Sociedad stun Real
Napoli edge past Genoa, Inter held
Champions PSG too good for St Etienne
Stewart makes early exit on Nascar return
Zimbabwe thrashing rips open Aussies scars
Oman Sail and Thales provide sailing opportunity for children
Wozniacki sends Sharapova packing

Sports


International

© 2013 Oman Tribune. All rights reserved. Best viewed in 800 X 600 resolution