Omantribune
Oman Tribune
Omantribune
Omantribune Search News
Web Oman
    Google Search Button
      Tribune
- Oman
- Soccer World Cup
- Other Top Stories
- Middle East
- Business
- Sports
- India
- Pakistan
- Asia
- Europe
- Americas
- Columnists
- Editorial
- Oman Mirror
- Special Features
- Cinema
- PDF Pages
- Weather
- Travel
- Currency Rate
- Hospitals
- Pharmacies
- Services
- Flight Timings
- Museum Timings
Omantribune Home Omantribune About Us Omantribune Advertising Information Omantribune Archives Omantribune Subscribe-Form Omantribune Jobs Omantribune Contact Us
Thursday, May 23, 2013  
A political ‘alchemist’?

by Marcel Van Silfhout
Wilders’ popularity will be on test at the coming provincial polls

Some people perfectly know how to play semantic tricks, especially when it’s about politics. I tried to avoid writing about the controversial right-wing anti-Islam politician Geert Wilders for a while, but it’s impossible to ignore the present worrisome political phenomenon as the campaign for the Dutch provincial elections will begin on March 2. Wilders is a sort of political alchemist, in another sense, who can turn trust into distrust and freedom of expression into a boycott of free media. Perhaps he will be able to turn gold into mud. The question is will he be successful in the upcoming elections again?

In the last few weeks, some bizarre proposals have been heard. The strange thing is nobody seems to take notice of them anymore when awful lines are spoken. In a popular Dutch talk show, one of the prominent politicians from Wilders’ Party of Freedom – please take note of the mismatch of the word ‘freedom’ – said he wants to ban woman’s headscarf in provincial offices. A few days later, another PVV candidate went even further. He wanted to ban the headscarves in public busses. It’s all said live on the TV in the Netherlands.

The presenter of the talk show asked: “So you even want the Dutch police to stop a bus when someone is wearing a headscarf and then take that woman out?” The PVV candidate answered straight, “yes,” leaving the presenter aghast. But, in a riposte, he asked, “That’s even worse than what happened once in the United States, when you we’re a nigger you perhaps weren’t allowed to sit, but they at least were allowed on the bus!”

Of course, there was a moment of uneasy silence at the talk show table. Other guests looked as if they saw water burning. But still, in a few minutes, the incident seemed to have been forgotten. The other day, some political parties made a lot of buzz about what the PVV member said, but within days the racist-like ‘incident’ wasn’t discussed any more.

Perhaps the alchemist tricks of Wilders and his ‘freedom party’ have a lot to do with the art of being utterly brutal. Before the headscarf ban issue, supported by the Wilders party, died down, another provocative one-liner was heard.

The Netherlands need to build ‘tuigdorpen’ meaning ‘villages for scum’, the populist Wilders was quoted as saying in the Dutch newspaper De Telegraaf. The idea behind this plan is to put all the trouble-makers in fenced villages, owned and guarded by government. Indeed, how perverse can one be?

It’s this kind of ‘brutal semantic alchemy’ which is vitiating the Dutch society. A large group of  right-wing electorate seems to enjoy this sort of provocative language as a counter-approach to presumed soft left-wing politics, while the leftist and centrist electorate shiver over such horrifying and de-humanising ideas like a ban on headscarves and ‘scum villages.’

It’s an amazing and surrealistic experience to see how Egypt seems to move in the direction of more democracy, while a popular party in the Netherlands is openly excluding Muslims and other groups from society under the flag of a ‘freedom party.’ Of course, Wilders PVV still isn’t the one and only political party in the Netherlands with its 15.5 per cent of the Dutch vote. But now since he is supporting and tolerating a right-wing minority coalition government, his power is immense.

The coming provincial elections are the first ‘referendum’ for the Netherlands in saying yes or no to the current minority government. It’s a matter of consolidating Wilders and his PVV in the Dutch society against a ‘No’ to him and the cabinet he is supporting.

The reason for this is that the provinces will elect the ‘First Chamber,’ the senate in Holland. If Wilders and the Liberals and Christian Democrats won’t get a majority in the senate, they can’t rule the country anymore.

Last week Wilders proved again to be a turnaround alchemist. In a cartoon on a website of a progressive public broadcast company his proposal for special villages was satirically presented as a Nazi-camp lookalike. Wilders, who recently defended the ‘freedom of speech’ for anti-Islam cartoonists, said he would boycott the broadcast company if it would not pull back the cartoon.

Wilders was confronted with the fact that he has always seen himself as a martyr of ‘freedom of expression.’ So, why did he bother this time now?  Was it because he was a ‘victim of freedom of expression’? Can’t he deal with criticism directed at him?

The outcome of the next provincial elections is unclear. Opinion polls aren’t worth much. The fact is the political landscape in the Netherlands is definitively out of synch.

At the same time the word ‘freedom’ is severely abused by Wilders. The utilitarian liberal philosopher John Stuart Mill once wrote a famous book ‘On Liberty’. And although Mill isn’t my favourite as a founding father of liberalism, Wilders should take his lines seriously with his presumed ‘liberal roots.’ For Mill the most important basis of liberty is the ‘sovereign individual.’

The opposite of that is the ‘tyranny of the majority’ wherein through control of etiquette and morality society can do horrific things. Mill’s liberal ‘harm principle’ is apparently unknown to Wilders: “People can do anything they like as long as it does not harm others.”

 (Marcel van Silfhout is an investigative reporter working for public Dutch Television)

Oman Tribune

Other comment for Marcel Van Silfhout

European solidarity in great danger

A big happy family in the Netherlands

A case of inhumanity in the Netherlands

Golden Age returns to The Netherlands

From Russia with plenty of love

The Netherlands is a tax paradise

Ice cold government that has no empathy

A nightmare is unfolding in Europe

Fallow deer becoming a pest for the Dutch

News stories revealed, and on-the-record...

There’s good news for culture vultures

An instance of cultural stupidity

There is great fear in the Netherlands

The devastating fissures in Europe

A forgotten murder case is back in focus

No reason for any kind of euphoria

New political era

Moral support

Hidden but real

Changing times

Birthday bashing

Dutch ‘mediacracy’

European psychosis

Thinking of Holland

Judgment Day

Dutch decision time

Nothing is sacred

Surreal, bizarre

Shock and awe

Leave us alone

Miracle needed

Strange but true

Dirt everywhere

Peace is a pause

It’s up to the Greeks

Cautious optimism

Decade of turmoil

Different times

Mistake rectified

Dreams die

Lunatic idea

The past haunts

Time alone will tell

Horror ahead

Not an ideal world

Desire for harmony

No owners

World is not enough...

The agony and ecstasy

Bankers and morality

Christmas thoughts

Nothing new

End of solidarity

Major change

Strange scenario

Clash of egos

Fear is the key

A question of identity

Grievous sin

The Matheo Solution

Farewell ‘Mr Freedom’

No-fly zone role in ‘liberation’

Boost to Oman-Dutch ties

Arab events confuse Europe

Wrong side of history

A political ‘alchemist’?

The world is out of synch

Exodus from Holland

Sparring with WikiLeaks

A brave new world is here

A Dutch Bhopal

A white Xmas after 30 years

‘The Monster’of Holland

Grumpy, snowy Europe

Wrestling with WikiLeaks

A visit to the Sultanate

A night reminiscent of 1999

Talking about ghosts

Once upon a time...

A ghost story in wintertime

How to blow up faith 

Europe tolerant no more

Populist politics on the rise

Devastating Wilders show

How to conquer populism

After Roma who?

A giant pension lie

The rise of populism

A nightmarish scenario

Sail Amsterdam

Post-colonial ghost is back

Paradoxes and puzzles

National state of confusion

Death knell for innovation

Laws of attraction

culprits in DSB collapse

Media trial sans court case

Orange marketing

Democracy in crisis

Caterpillar invasion

A Garlic Pact

A volcanic message

Miscarriage of justice

H-word no longer taboo

Church of child abuse

Hope versus fear

Right-wing extremism

Out of plumb

The Netherlands’ misery bin

Why the euro is on a slide

The forbidden ‘thing’

Spyker-Saab fairytale

Back to the fifties

Politics and integrity

Winter depression

An awful truth

Need for a new strategy

Lessons in modesty

Israel is losing a friend

The rise and fall of DSB

Oman gives Dutch a treat

Controversies galore

Caught in a crisis

A ship in bad weather

Bankers’ bonus mania

When every second counts

A horrifying beach party

Conflict of interest

Goodbye Mr Nato

H1N1 holiday

A Dutch secret

A tarnished image

A Wilders alarm

Paper dilemma

Housing for the poor?

No interest in future

The rise of right

History caught in a knot

Prison dilemmas

Crisis, what crisis?

A nation in grief

A depressed nation

Hovering over Holland

A meeting in the zoo

Smoking ban hurts

A ‘good’ Dutch model

Crisis on a crisis plan

Archives
- Back to columns -
NEWS UPDATES
Oman
ROHM higher panel holds meeting
Rafo band performs in Paris
Shura committees discuss draft on waste management, land and labour laws
Solutions for border security discussed
Shura to host Rawiyah
Flight makes first test landing at new Sohar Airport
Bridgestone tyre safety road show begins
Other Top Stories
UK soldier killed in terror attack in London street
Iran instals N-equipment at Natanz
Sultanate to buy air defence system
40 killed in Iraq attacks
Plans to address sexual assault in military unveiled
India
India, US seek elimination of terror havens
Shayan Munshi, ballistic expert to be tried for perjury in Jessica case
UPA ministers’ names will surface in IPL scam: Swamy
Military equipment wish list given to federal government, says Karzai
BrahMos successfully test-fired from ship
Plea filed against court holidays
Singh isn’t leader of Congress nor country, says BJP
NIA files indictment against four in Malegaon blasts case
Sharma as CAG could lead to conflict of interest: BJP
Stench of corruption, misgovernance take shine off UPA’s record
No consensus on minimum wages
FB, Google asked about kids’ online safety
Pakistan
Trade ties with China to get boost
Nawaz, Zardari agree to face challenges together
Court rejects Musharraf bail in judges’ case
CNG use in large vehicles banned
Imran leaves hospital
ECP draws flak for charging fee to verify thumbprints
Middle East
Nejad to contest Mashaie’s ‘unjust’ disqualification
Seven Egyptian security men kidnapped in Sinai released
Al Jazeera tops Arab news channels in Mideast
Government drive to cut energy subsidies hits Egyptian factories
Asian workers in UAE ‘end strike’
Israel’s newfound gas to boost regional clout
Asia
US senators back lifting sanctions against Myanmar
Myanmar reforms will accelerate pace of economic renaissance, says IMF
600 Afghan interpreters who helped UK to get visas
Farmers resume paddy cultivation near doomed Fukushima nuclear plant
Hawkish general returns as N. Korea army chief
N. Korea sends top official to China to mend ties
Business
Oman Air places order for three A330-300 aircraft
Board okays projects worth 155.69m rials
Dubai faces $9.4b maturing debt this year amid recovery
IMF urges UK to do more to boost growth
PC vows to plug regulatory gaps in financial sector
L&T posts 7% fall in Q4 profit
Britvic to launch Fruit Shoot brand in India
Sri Lanka to get 1m barrels Omani crude to resume refinery operations
Weak yen fails to boost Japan exports as trade deficit widens
US to push Bangladesh on factory reform
BoJ to keep further easing on hold as GDP picks up
Sony weighs entertainment arm spin-off
BlackBerry looks to focus on services to regain market share
Europe
EU leaders step up fight against banking secrecy
Swedish capital hit by third day of riots, PM calls for calm
Man charged over ‘82 IRA troop bombings in London
Recession, soaring unemployment reduce millions to penury in Italy
French activist kills self after gay marriage rant
Life term sought for over 100 army officers in Turkey coup trial
Sports
Oman to have own cricket academy
Afghan cricket captain’s father kidnapped
Pakistan raring to go against Ireland in ODIs
Ankle injury forces Lanka’s Welegedara out
Spurs hold off late-charging Grizzlies
Pellegrini to leave Malaga
Napoli’s Mazzarri to join Inter
Australia ready for Ashes scrap
Warner pleads guilty over twitter rant, fined by CA
New Zealand’s Watling out of second Test
Garcia apologises for ‘fried chicken’ jibe
I wouldn’t have won sans short putter: Els
Suwaiq clinch League title
Oman beat Iran 3-1 in friendly encounter
Hodge steers Rajasthan Royals to qualifier
Al Harthy hopes to continue good start to season at Silverstone

Sports


International

© 2013 Oman Tribune. All rights reserved. Best viewed in 800 X 600 resolution